Field note 10 · Campaigns · Field Notes
Is a Black Friday discount right for your business?
Sometimes, and sometimes it quietly costs you. A discount reliably brings volume. What it does not promise is the right customers: a price cut can fill your busiest week with people who came only for the price and never return. Whether it helps depends on who you sell to, and that you can work out before you decide.
Key takeaways
- A discount is a filter, and it selects for the one thing it advertises: price. For a business whose edge is price and volume that is the right crowd; for one whose edge is quality, trust or service, a blanket cut can fill the week with the wrong people.
- Three quiet costs: margin given up on people who would have paid full price, one-time buyers who never come back, and loyal customers trained to wait for the next sale. None of it shows in the Black Friday week itself.
- Check your own records before you decide: of your last ten or twenty customers, how many first came in on a discount, and how many of those ever bought again at full price?
The symptom.
Every competitor is running a sale, so the pressure to match them is hard to ignore. You cut your price, the orders climb for a week, and then it goes quiet again. The spike looks like a win, but the customers it brought behave nothing like your best ones, and the month after is flatter than the month before.
What a discount actually does.
A discount is a filter, and it selects for the one thing it advertises: price. It pulls in the people most moved by a lower number, who are also the most likely to leave for the next lower number somewhere else. For a business whose real edge is price and volume, that is exactly the right crowd. For one whose edge is quality, trust or service, a blanket cut can fill the week with the wrong people and teach your existing customers to wait for the next sale.
What it costs.
Three quiet costs. You give up margin on people who would have paid full price anyway. You draw one-time buyers who cost as much to serve and never come back, which can look like growth while really bringing you the wrong leads. And you train loyal customers to treat your everyday price as optional, so they hold off and buy only when you cut it. None of this shows in the Black Friday week itself, which is why the sale always looks as though it worked.
Check your own, before you decide.
You do not need a tool for this, just an honest look at your own records. Take your last ten or twenty customers. How many first came in on a discount, and of those, how many ever bought again at the full price? If the discount buyers rarely return, a bigger sale will mostly bring you more of the same. If they do come back and become regulars, a sale may genuinely be worth running. The answer is in your own history, not in what your competitors are doing this week.
What we would look at first.
Who your best customers are, and what actually brought them in, because that is who a sale should be aimed at, or kept away from. Whether your real edge is price, or something a discount hides rather than helps. Whether a time-limited offer to past customers would do more than a blanket cut aimed at strangers. This is a question about your business, not your website, and it can be answered before Black Friday rather than after it.
Two questions this raises.
- So should I skip Black Friday altogether?
- Not necessarily. The point is to choose on purpose. A sale aimed at people who already value you, or a clear offer that protects your margin, is a very different thing from matching a rival's cut because the date arrived. Decide who you want to walk in, then build the offer for them.
- Is this the same as my website not being ready?
- No, and both matter. One is whether your site can carry the week, which has its own note. This is the earlier question: whether the sale is the right move for your business at all. A ready website pointed at the wrong customers still costs you.
Next steps
Where to go from here.
If this sounds like your business.
Start with who you actually want to serve. A Signal Audit is a clear outside look at who your best customers are and what brings them in, so a sale, or a decision not to run one, is aimed rather than guessed. And if you do run an offer, a sharp targeted campaign to the right people will nearly always beat a blanket discount to everyone.
Start a Signal AuditRelated: Campaigns, the work this note usually leads to · What should I fix before Black Friday?