Field note 01 · Enquiries · Field Notes

Why do I keep getting the wrong leads?

Because the wrong leads are a reasonable reply to an unclear offer. A business that sells many things to many kinds of customer reads as vague from the outside, and vagueness attracts everybody, including the people you did not want. The enquiries are not the problem. They are an accurate response to what you published.

Key takeaways

  • The wrong leads are an accurate reply to an unclear offer, so the enquiries are not the thing that needs fixing.
  • Ask three people in the business, separately, to say in one sentence what it does and who it is for. Different answers mean the offer is too broad.
  • Narrowing is mostly tidying. You are not giving up work, you are taking down a sign for a shop you closed.

What it looks like from inside.

The enquiries come in. Some are for quantities you do not sell. Some want a thing you did once, three years ago, that is still on the website. Some are right on paper and then the first call is twenty minutes of you explaining what you actually do. You start to say "we get leads, but they are never the right ones", and you say it as if it were a marketing problem. It is not.

What it looks like from outside.

A stranger reads your website for six seconds and draws a conclusion. If the page lists nine services, four industries and a mission statement, the conclusion is "they do a bit of everything". That stranger then either leaves, or writes to you about the one thing on the list that nobody inside wants to do. The website is not lying. It is repeating what the business has not decided.

What it costs.

Every wrong lead costs a first call, a proposal you write knowing it will not land, and the hour you spend afterwards wondering why. Add those up over a quarter and you find that the wrong leads are not free. They are the most expensive thing in the sales pipeline, because they consume the same time as the right ones and pay nothing.

Where the broad offer came from.

Most of the time it was not a decision. It is a record.

Somebody asked whether you also did the other thing, and you did it once, and it went on the website. A client needed something adjacent and you learned it over a weekend. A service you have not sold since 2023 is still listed because nobody remembered to take it down. None of that was wrong at the time. Each yes was a sensible yes.

The result is a list that describes your history rather than your business. A stranger reading it is not looking at a strategy. They are looking at an archaeology, and they will pick whichever layer sounds most like their problem, which is very often the layer you least want to dig up again.

That is also why narrowing feels like loss when it is mostly tidying. You are not giving up work. You are taking down a sign for a shop you closed.

The test.

Ask three people in the business, separately, to say in one sentence what it does and for whom. If you get three different sentences, the offer is too broad. The leads are not the wrong ones. They are the right response to a wrong message.

How to narrow it, in order.

The order matters, because most businesses do the last step first and wonder why nothing changed.

  1. List everything you currently sell, including the things you stopped selling but never took off the site.
  2. Put last year's revenue against each line. Not the number you hoped for. The number that arrived.
  3. Cross off anything that earned less than it cost to deliver, and anything you dread seeing in the diary.
  4. Write one sentence naming what is left and who it is for.
  5. Change the website, the proposal template and the first line of your calls to that sentence, on the same day.

Step five is the one that gets skipped, and it is the only one a customer can see. A sentence that exists in a meeting and a document changes nothing. The same sentence on the page a stranger reads is the whole fix.

If you want to know what that page is currently saying, the Pulse Check is free and takes about twenty seconds. It reads your page the way a search engine does, which is not the way you read it.

What fixes it.

Fewer things, named plainly, priced on purpose. The products and customers the numbers say to keep, and the ones to stop apologising for. Then one sentence that everyone inside can say the same way. That sentence becomes the website, the proposal and the first thirty seconds of every call, and the wrong leads stop, because they were never being sold to. This is the first fix in Fix & Grow, and it is the first thing a Signal Audit looks at, because it is the one that changes the other two.

What narrowing does not mean.

It does not mean turning away work you already have. The clients on your books now are not affected by what the website says tomorrow, and nothing here asks you to resign an account.

It does not mean putting your prices up. That is a separate decision with its own arguments, and bundling it in here is how a sensible change becomes an argument about money.

It does not mean picking a niche in the way that word is usually used, where a business announces it serves one industry and quietly keeps taking everything else. A narrow offer is about what you sell, not about who you will speak to. You can sell one clearly described thing to eleven different industries.

And it does not mean you were doing it wrong. A broad offer is what a business looks like while it is finding out what it is good at. The problem is only that the finding-out stays on the website long after the finding is done.

Two questions this raises.

How do I know if my offer is too broad?
Ask three people in the business to describe it in one sentence, separately. Three different sentences means it is too broad.
Will narrowing the offer lose customers?
It loses the ones the numbers say you should not have. It keeps the ones who pay, and it makes the next ones easier to find.

Next steps

Where to go from here.

If this is your business, the audit starts here.

From half a day, both of us, your numbers. A written diagnosis that says whether this is the problem, and what to fix first.

Start a Signal Audit

Related: Websites, the work this note usually leads to · Why does every sale take three meetings? · Why do my leads go quiet after I send a proposal?

X viewfinder   L lift everything   I index   Esc close