Field note 03 · Social · Field Notes
Why does nothing change when we post?
Because nothing changes when we post until the story inside has been agreed. The story outside is only ever as strong as the story inside, and a business cannot broadcast a decision it has not made, so the posts have nothing solid to carry.
Key takeaways
- Posts cannot carry a decision the business has not made, so volume is not what is holding the content back.
- Read your last ten posts as a stranger and write what each one leaves behind. More than two different things and the problem is not frequency.
- The likes come from staff, friends and suppliers. The audience that matters reads a few posts, decides, and leaves no trace at all.
What it looks like.
A post every week, sometimes two. A designer or an agency or the owner's nephew making it look tidy. Likes from staff and friends. Enquiries: the same as before. The owner concludes that content does not work for businesses like theirs, or that the algorithm is against them, or that they need to post more. None of those is the finding.
The likes are not a small signal. They are a different signal.
The posts do get a response, which is what makes this so hard to let go of.
Look at who it comes from. Staff, their partners, your suppliers, two competitors keeping an eye on you, a cousin, and the people you were at school with. Every one of those is a real person and none of them is a customer. They are responding to you rather than to the offer, which is a kind thing to do and tells you nothing about whether the offer landed.
The audience you actually want is not in that number, because a stranger who is not yet looking for you has no reason to react to anything. When that person does arrive, months later, they will not like a post. They will read four or five of them quickly, decide whether this is a business that knows what it is, and leave either way without touching anything.
So the number you can see is made of people who already know you, and the audience that matters leaves no trace at all. That is not a reason to despair at it. It is a reason to stop using it as the measure.
What the posts are actually saying.
Look at the last ten posts as a stranger. Not as the owner, who knows what was meant. As someone who has never heard of the business. Most of the time they say ten slightly different things, because each was written on the day about whatever was happening. Ten different things, repeated weekly, add up to nothing a customer can remember, let alone repeat to a colleague.
- Open your last ten posts in order, oldest first.
- Write one sentence under each saying what a stranger would take away. Not what you meant by it.
- Close the posts and read your ten sentences on their own.
- Count how many different things they say.
- If it is more than two, the problem is not how often you post.
Step three is the one that makes this work. Read next to the post, every sentence looks fine, because the picture is doing half the explaining and your memory is doing the other half. Read on their own, ten sentences that say ten things are very hard to mistake for a message.
The tell.
When did a customer last repeat your marketing back to you in their own words? If the answer is "never", the posts are not landing, and it is not because of the posting. It is because there is no single sentence for them to land on.
Why more posting makes it worse.
Volume amplifies whatever the message is. If the message is a blur, more posts make a bigger blur, faster, at more cost. This is the reason the Grow step comes last in the way we work, and why campaigns come last inside it. Paid reach multiplies. We do not switch it on until there is something worth multiplying.
What fixes it.
Not a content calendar. A decision. What the business is, for whom, and why it is the one to call, written down and agreed inside before anything goes outside. Then content, film and campaigns that all say that one thing in different ways, made by someone who knows how to make a stranger feel it. That is Albie's work, and it waits, deliberately, for the diagnosis.
What to do with the month you are not posting.
Saying stop posting leaves an obvious gap, so here is what the month is for.
Write the sentence. One sentence naming what the business does, who it is for, and why it is the right choice. It will take longer than you expect, not because the writing is hard but because the deciding is.
Then test it on people outside the building. Say it to three customers you are comfortable with and ask them to say it back in their own words a week later. If it comes back close, it has landed. If it comes back as something else, you have learned more in a week than a quarter of posting would have told you.
Then change the website before you change anything else. It is the page a stranger reads and the page a machine reads, it is working while you are asleep, and unlike a post it does not scroll away in a day. If you want to know what a machine currently takes from it, the Pulse Check is free and takes about twenty seconds.
Only then go back to posting, with something to say. A month of silence costs very little. A year of posting a blur costs a great deal, and it also teaches your audience that you are not worth reading, which is the part that takes longest to undo.
Two questions this raises.
- Should we stop posting until the story is decided?
- Posting less is usually the right call. Posting nothing for a month costs almost nothing. Posting a blur for a year costs a great deal.
- How do we know the story has landed?
- A customer says it back to you, unprompted, in words close to yours. Until that happens, keep the volume down and the decision sharp.
Next steps
Where to go from here.
If this is your business, the audit starts here.
From half a day, both of us, your numbers. A written diagnosis that says whether this is the problem, and what to fix first.
Start a Signal AuditRelated: Social, the work this note usually leads to · Why marketing reports look good but nothing improves